Confirmed Starbucks Knows The Next Hot Neighborhood Before Everybody Else Does
Confirmed Starbucks Knows The Next Hot Neighborhood Before Everybody Else Does
What fuels gentrification? The answer is the same thing that fuels the rest of us: coffee.
But not just any old cup oâ joe.
Starbucks, the iconic coffee roaster and retailer, has grown into a $15 billion company, with more than 19,000 locations in more than 60 countries. You can spot that familiar green-and-white logo from Saudi Arabia to Switzerland, in a Dubai shopping mall, or on a Carnival Cruise ship. Where the Berlin Wall once stood, thereâs a shiny new Starbucks instead. Conveniently, one of our desks has a view of the original Starbucks store in Pike Place Market.
Starbucksâ mission is âto inspire and nurture the human spiritâone person, one cup and one neighborhood at a time.â Any college student downing venti caramel macchiatos to stay awake the night before a big exam can testify to Starbucksâ, in a word, nurturing qualities. But as it turns out, Starbucks correlates with something else, too: rising home values.
To explore exactly how closely the two correlate, we compared a database of Starbucks locations with Zillow data. And since Starbucksâ corporate headquarters in Seattle is located just a few miles down the road from Zillow, we also took the opportunity to pay our neighbors a visit, and to pick the brains of Starbucksâ own real estate analytics teamâthe whizzes who determine where to put that next Starbucks location.
Hereâs what we can tell you: Starbucks equates with venti-sized home-value appreciation. Moreover, Starbucks seems to be fuelingânot followingâthese higher home values.
And the reason why is that Starbucksâ real estate choices are, in their words, âas much an art as a science.â When deciding where to hang its next shingle, the company marries right-brain ingenuity with hard-headed, left-brain analysisâexactly as you should.
Letâs take these fresh-brewed insights one at a time.
Starbucks equals big bucks
Although some may scoff that the predictive value of a given retail chain doesnât mean much, locations near Starbucks are, indisputably, highly lucrative.
True, properties near Starbucks locations tend to start out more expensive. But as you can see, these properties appreciate at a faster rate than US housing on the whole. Interestingly, theyâre also recovering much more quickly from the housing bust.
What does that look like in practice? Letâs look at the historical home value appreciation of areas that now are located within a quarter mile of a Starbucks. A home that is now near a Starbucks would have sold, on average, for $137,000. A home that is not near a Starbucks would have sold, on average, for $102,000.
Fast-forward 17 years to 2014. That average American home has now appreciated 65%, to $168,000. But the Starbucks-adjacent property has far outpaced that, appreciating 96% to $269,000.
Starbucks is the fuel, not the follower
âTry some decaf,â you may be thinking. âHome prices rise and fall for a lot of reasons. How do we know this has anything to do with Starbucks?â For instance, maybe this isnât a Starbucks Effect at all. Maybe itâs just a coffeeshop effect.
To examine that possibility, we took a look at another prominent coffee chain, Dunkinâ Donuts.
What did we learn? Homes near Dunkinâ Donuts reflect a similar historical trend. But while they appreciate faster than the nationâs housing as a whole, they still donât appreciate as fast as properties that are now a quarter-mile from a Starbucks.
In fact, between 1997 and 2012, homes now located near Starbucks and Dunkinâ Donuts followed similar historical trajectories, substantially outpacing the overall home value appreciation. But their paths diverged during the recent housing recovery such that, today, homes near Dunkinâ Donuts have appreciated 80% since 1997 whereas homes near Starbucks have appreciated 96%, almost doubling their value.
Even so, you may be saying, is it possible that the Starbucks Effect is really just a coastal effect? Or an urban effect?
Maybe people really like living in Seattle and Boston, and the Starbucks locations dotting their neighborhoods are just incidental. We wondered this, too. After all, when we looked at a map of Starbucks locations in the United States, itâs readily apparent that historically they have clustered on the coasts, in the Midwest, and in urban areas.
Moreover, maybe Starbucks and Dunkinâ Donuts are just waiting for a neighborhoodâs property values to heat up before moving in and setting up shop. Whatâs to say that Starbucks is the cause, rather than a consequence, of higher home values?
To attempt to rule out these possibilities, we tracked values of homes in a very tight ring within a quarter mile of Starbucks (so close you could practically smell the dark roast from your front porch) and compared those very-Starbucks-adjacent homes to houses slightly farther away, in a ring of homes between a quarter- and a half-mile from a Starbucks. And we compared home values in these two rings (adjacent and nearby) for only the five years after the Starbucks location actually opened, in order to see whether the effect took place after the opening or already existed before the store opened.
Lo and behold, the adjacent homes beat out the nearby homes. Those houses closest to Starbucks appreciated a little more than 21% over five years, while the houses slightly farther away only appreciated just less than 17%. So, yes, some of the difference is related to the location itself, but thereâs still a healthy difference attributable to the arrival of a Starbucks.
Whatever the reasonsâbecause they genuinely like drinking coffee, or because they see Starbucks as a proxy for gentrificationâit seems pretty clear that people are paying a premium for homes near Starbucks. And furthermore, it looks like Starbucks itself is driving the increase in home values.
Picking locationsâAn art and a science
Armed with this data, we headed down Seattleâs First Avenue to Starbucks HQ. There, we had the pleasure of chatting with Arthur Rubinfeld, who oversees Starbucksâ location selection process, and his extremely talented team. We asked them, is the Starbucks Effect the product of careful, data-driven decisions on their part? And their answer was, more or less, yes.
The Starbucks team explained that while they have 20 or so analytics experts around the world poring over maps and geographic information systems dataâassessing factors like an areaâs traffic patterns and businessesâthe company also empowers dozens of regional teams to come to their own conclusions about location, store design, and a host of other issues.
Yet, even with their reams of data and locally-driven decision making, our Starbucks friends noted that there was no single silver bullet. âThe beauty of Starbucks is our understanding of real-estate site locationing,â Arthur told us. âItâs an art and a science.â
We couldnât have put it better ourselves.
There have been times and placesâlike before the financial crisis, when Starbucks bet on an up-and-coming Seattle commercial area that never materializedâwhere the art of site location is displayed in all of its messiness. In other instances, the science has delivered big-time returns.
Ultimately, one Starbucks pro told us, âWe try to provide consistency in the scienceâŠ so that local decision makers have everything they need at their fingertips to make easy decisions.â
Indeed, at the end of the day, where you buy a home is based on countless subjective factors. As in Moby-Dickâwhose pages gave us the first mate Starbuck and inspired the Starbucks nameâfinding that perfect, ahead-of-the- curve home can sometimes seem like chasing your very own white whale. But some factors can make that search a little bit easier. So grab a venti skim latteâhey, get the extra shotâand go find the right home for you.
This is excerpted from Zillow Talk: The New Rules of Real Estate by Spencer Rascoff and Stan Humphries. Published by Grand Central Publishing this month, it is available at bookstores and online at zillow.com.
Author:HGR LEADS Phone: 214-239-1889 Dated: January 31st 2015 Views: 2,196 About HGR: ...
We understand that for many people, buying or selling a home is probably the largest investment decision that they will make in their lifetime. Halo Group Realty LLC thus became active in selling Real Estate in 2008 and was setup to make this process a simple and painless transaction. Your dedicated agent will guide you every step of the way to make purchasing or selling your home enjoyable and excitingâŠ as it should be!
Today, Halo Group Realty LLC is at the cutting edge of technology in offering assistance to those in need of real estate services, and we have revolutionized the method of delivering education to consumers. Halo is established as the place for consumers to get the knowledge and assistance they deserve in the process of facilitating the Real Estate transaction, positioning you in the best possible situation to get the best price when you either to buy or sell. With leadership, innovation and forward thinking, Halo Group Realty, LLC is poised to make a huge impression in the real estate market while providing clients the keys to home ownership.
Our goal is to help make your dream a reality and take away all of the stress that goes along with purchasing or selling your home. Whether you are purchasing new construction, an existing home, or just an open space for future enjoyment, representation by a Halo agent is a valuable tool in making your dream become a reality.